Blog / Local Information / Where to Get Ice Cream in Watch Hill, Rhode Island

Where to Get Ice Cream in Watch Hill, Rhode Island

photo of ice cream

Wandering through Westerly's Watch Hill village is a popular pastime for locals and visitors alike, as this affluent community features an abundance of boutique shops and some of the state's best dining.

Watch Hill is also home to a couple of scenic beaches, the village's famous merry-go-round, and the Napatree Point Conservation Area.

With so many activities from which to choose as you spend time in Watch Hill, you might find yourself looking for a meal or even just a quick treat to help you cool down in the summer heat.

Fortunately, there are a few places you can grab an ice cream or other frozen goody in the Bay Street area, so you can continue on your way as you explore Watch Hill village.

Here's a look at where locals get their ice cream in Watch Hill.

Pompelmo By The Sea

For authentic Italian gelato in Watch Hill, Pompelmo By The Sea is the place to visit. This small ice cream shop is steps from the merry-go-round and Watch Hill Beach, making it easily accessible when spending a day in the sun.

Pompelmo By The Sea's owners spent time in Italy learning how to create authentic gelato from scratch and have been providing their flavors to Watch Hill residents since 2019. Every item on the menu is handmade daily in small batches, ensuring you can sample the freshest gelato around.

The menu at Pompelmo By The Sea is relatively simple, as they offer about a dozen flavors. These flavors change seasonally, but you'll usually find vanilla, chocolate, and dark chocolate sorbet available. Seasonal menu items include hazelnut, pistachio, strawberry, peanut butter, and cookie monster.

In addition to the ice cream, Pompelmo By The Sea has vegan floats, traditional root beer floats, and gelato sandwiches, giving you all kinds of options every time you visit.

St. Clair Annex

Pompelmo By The Sea isn't the only option for ice cream near Watch Hill Beach, as St. Clair Annex sits right beside the merry-go-round.

All the ice cream at St. Clair Annex is made on-site using locally sourced milk, and they have dozens of flavors available for you to sample. Some of their most popular offerings include coconut pineapple, cookie dough, Oreo, peach, and chocolate chip.

They have frozen yogurt, a soft-serve machine, chocolate and cherry dips, a variety of toppings, and multiple flavors of sundaes, too.

The great thing about St. Clair Annex is that there's a full restaurant there, as well, so you can grab a meal at the same time, including their famous lobster roll.

You can stop in for an ice cream cone to-go or a full sitdown meal at St. Clair Annex, and you'll probably find yourself doing both from time to time as you spend more time in Watch Hill.

Ten Sandwiches

There will be times where you aren't in the mood for an ice cream cone, and Ten Sandwiches has you covered.

As its name suggests, Ten Sandwiches is a sandwich restaurant featuring ten different options on its menu. They also serve salads and have breakfast until 11 AM.

If you're in the mood for a cold treat, Ten Sandwiches serves five different smoothie flavors, including options with strawberry, banana, pineapple, blueberry, and coconut milk. They have iced coffee, too.

Most ingredients used by Ten Sandwiches are organic, and they source items locally whenever possible.

Ten Sandwiches is proof that you can focus on your health while still enjoying frozen goodies in the summer. 

The General Store

Finally, you don't have to visit an ice cream shop or restaurant to grab some ice cream because The General Store at the Watch Hill Harbor House Inn has a selection of packaged treats for you.

The General Store is more of a convenience store than anything else, but you can grab all the cold snacks you could ever dream of and be on your way in no time at all.

The ice cream shops in Watch Hill are great, but sometimes you just want something familiar before carrying on with your day, and that's precisely what The General Store provides for its customers.

Enjoy Watch Hill in the Summer

Filling your time walking through Watch Hill or lounging on its beaches could become some of your favorite activities after buying a home in South County. The weather is often beautiful in this part of the state, and you might find yourself spending week after week throughout the summer enjoying it. 

You'll want to cool off, though, because sitting in the sun all day is never a good idea.

The ice cream shops in Watch Hill provide the perfect opportunity to sample some of South County's finest desserts while beating the summer heat. 

Make sure you check them out the next time you're looking for an ice cream cone in the Watch Hill area.


Published July 5, 2021 in Local Information, Exploring South County